I'd rant about the lack of a realy story or immersion, but old school style game gets judged as an old school style game. Aside from that, the main reason it can't get five or four stars? This should've been harder. I haven't finished the game yet, but I have played up to level 75 or so. The game prior to the second run through, is fairly difficult and I had to think a bit before moving. After that first time, where I reached around level 10, I was able to get all the way to level 45, stopping only because I wanted to go get lunch. The game gets ridiculously easy, especially if you invest in either HP/MP Regen enchantments (kinda broken) or HP/MP Restoration (potions are very easy to come across and/or make). The interface was also very bad in organization of ingredients. It was pretty annoying shuffling through all that crap just to find something with a desired effect. Maybe next time organize them according to the effect?
On the plus side, the game is quite engrossing, if repetitive (of course a lot of games are actually very tedious in their core but thats a whole other discussion). It's very straightforward, which is a pro and con at the same time. Decent time killer though. Worth playing.