At 8/14/18 07:54 AM, TomFulp wrote: Updated to HTTP, hope it helps!

Thanks that's just what it needed (barring a universal fix for all Nutcasenightmare medal API games).

I was able to just now get a medal in one of the games even.

• 

  by <deleted>

  Under Judgment

  (Everyone)

Not sure about this one. I get it that he's trying to test out if the medals work, but as you can see they do not.

At 8/14/18 07:07 PM, SLjimbolian wrote: http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/715476
Not sure about this one. I get it that he's trying to test out if the medals work, but as you can see they do not.

Since it is still in the under judgment phase let's say the NG community should know what to do with this. I PMed the author suggesting the "voluntary withdrawal" of it, but got no response.

At 8/14/18 08:09 PM, HerbieG wrote:

At 8/14/18 07:07 PM, SLjimbolian wrote: http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/715476
Not sure about this one. I get it that he's trying to test out if the medals work, but as you can see they do not.

Yes I Was thinking I would work but I'm not a flash expert this is my first medal project I will try too better it

At 8/15/18 01:17 AM, Fidget-Playz wrote:

At 8/14/18 08:09 PM, HerbieG wrote:

At 8/14/18 07:07 PM, SLjimbolian wrote: http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/715476
Not sure about this one. I get it that he's trying to test out if the medals work, but as you can see they do not.

Yes I Was thinking I would work but I'm not a flash expert this is my first medal project I will try too better it

There is nothing wrong with trying something new. Good luck on your next game with medals that work correctly.

Yes I Was thinking I would work but I'm not a flash expert this is my first medal project I will try too better it

There is nothing wrong with trying something new. Good luck on your next game with medals that work correctly.

Thank you!

At 8/19/18 08:57 PM, RightTime wrote: Any progress with fixing CAZE's medal issues @CjElliott ?
http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/661651
Is there any chance that the issues with medals not unlocking on this game could be solved by reverting it to http? There hasn't been an unlock for it since September of 2017. I also tried my hand at trying to get them unlocked, just in case the author had fixed the medal issues since then. No dice on three different browsers.

That game is just all kinds of messed up. Certain medals never awarded or only awarded to one or two people.

The last level itself is broken and in fact not completable as you lose even if you win, and thus the final level medal on the three difficulties was never obtainable anyway, for at least that reason. You must play the game on high quality as you will lose in certain levels if played on medium or low quality due to extremely bad game design.

As for playing other difficulties, you basically can't, unless for some reason the game lets you. I do have some medals in hard because at some point the game was letting me play those levels (but not the levels in medium) for some reason.

The idea is each difficulty is supposed to unlock upon beating the previous, except since the last level is bugged you can't actually beat it, so if you beat it you instead lose instead of win.

This is why you will notice the vast majority of people only have the first 9 medals anyway. I certainly have the skill to get full medals completion in that game, if it wasn't bugged to all hell.

And keep in mind this is before whatever issues you're running into now, which I assume are different from those issues.
It has so many medal issues (and always has) it probably just needs to be de-medalled entirely.

If you're seen broken medals, now what?...

At 8/19/18 08:57 PM, RightTime wrote: Any progress with fixing CAZE's medal issues @CjElliott ?
http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/661651
Is there any chance that the issues with medals not unlocking on this game could be solved by reverting it to http? There hasn't been an unlock for it since September of 2017.

If the medals stopped to unlock during September 2017 then it is a clear indicator that https is the reason.
@TomFulp @Exedor - it's worth a try to switch it.
On the other hand it would be important to see at least one developer making the medals broken this way work under https, this would give us the knowledge of what goes wrong.

At 8/20/18 07:04 AM, HerbieG wrote: If the medals stopped to unlock during September 2017 then it is a clear indicator that https is the reason.
@TomFulp @Exedor - it's worth a try to switch it.

Done. Give it a few minutes to update and then try it out.

At 8/20/18 07:08 AM, Exedor wrote:

At 8/20/18 07:04 AM, HerbieG wrote: If the medals stopped to unlock during September 2017 then it is a clear indicator that https is the reason.
@TomFulp @Exedor - it's worth a try to switch it.

Done. Give it a few minutes to update and then try it out.

It already works and so do the medals :-)

I just found out there's two games that doesn't have medals anymore.

• 

  Retiring Day

  by SnailsAnimation

  It's time to retire in this funny skill game with a funky ambiance!

  Game

  26,383 Views

  (Everyone)

Use to be up there, just simply disappeared. Haven't gotten an answer why the 3 medals are gone.

Also there's no trace of that Fidget Tycoon game that was posted about a month and a half ago. It looks like has been completely wiped out from Portal. That's about 10 medals that are gone too.

At 8/20/18 04:52 PM, SLjimbolian wrote: I just found out there's two games that doesn't have medals anymore.
http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/580879
Use to be up there, just simply disappeared. Haven't gotten an answer why the 3 medals are gone.

I remember this game, these medals were not working anymore, so they were removed.

Also there's no trace of that Fidget Tycoon game that was posted about a month and a half ago. It looks like has been completely wiped out from Portal. That's about 10 medals that are gone too.

As for this one... it looks like the author took all his toys and just left. I asked him about it few weeks ago and he mentioned that it should have been just a scheduled update and the games will come back, but as you see that never happened. He removed all of his Newgrounds projects.

At 8/20/18 04:52 PM, SLjimbolian wrote: I just found out there's two games that doesn't have medals anymore.
http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/580879
Use to be up there, just simply disappeared. Haven't gotten an answer why the 3 medals are gone.

Whenever the medal updates are heavy negative, it means the medals have vanished.

Also there's no trace of that Fidget Tycoon game that was posted about a month and a half ago. It looks like has been completely wiped out from Portal. That's about 10 medals that are gone too.

Losing 10 medals at once is a huge, but the 13 from both these games will really can people to notice.

Thanks, for for explaining what happened here.

At 8/20/18 04:52 PM, SLjimbolian wrote:

Also there's no trace of that Fidget Tycoon game that was posted about a month and a half ago. It looks like has been completely wiped out from Portal. That's about 10 medals that are gone too.

Guess what? That game returned to the portal.
I didn't notice any changes, but at least it is back.

At 8/21/18 09:31 AM, HerbieG wrote:

At 8/20/18 04:52 PM, SLjimbolian wrote:

Also there's no trace of that Fidget Tycoon game that was posted about a month and a half ago. It looks like has been completely wiped out from Portal. That's about 10 medals that are gone too.

Guess what? That game returned to the portal.
I didn't notice any changes, but at least it is back.

It is good to see it return. There must of been some reason why it vanished the first time.

At 8/21/18 09:16 PM, RightTime wrote: The medals for the game CaGe still aren't working as of September 2017. It appears to be an https related issue.
http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/649855

Updating to HTTP

At 8/22/18 04:06 PM, RightTime wrote: The game Deathbash, previously reported by @Bobogoobo is having the same sort of problem.
http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/664329

Has there been an update about this game being corrected?

At 8/24/18 02:07 PM, RightTime wrote:

The custom levels on Zomby Birdy: Save de Pig by @kikill are not loading anymore. This means that all the custom level medals have been broken ever since. You can see that there hasn't been an unlock on any of them since September of 2016.
http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/622866

I remember this one. I tried to contact the author, but nothing has been done since the problem is rather caused by an external server that is probably down for good.

Since removing only few medals from a game should not break any stats I'll take a risk ;-)

At 8/24/18 02:19 PM, HerbieG wrote: I remember this one. I tried to contact the author, but nothing has been done since the problem is rather caused by an external server that is probably down for good.

Since removing only few medals from a game should not break any stats I'll take a risk ;-)

I'm setting both of these last two to HTTP for good measure.

At 8/24/18 02:26 PM, TomFulp wrote:

At 8/24/18 02:19 PM, HerbieG wrote: I remember this one. I tried to contact the author, but nothing has been done since the problem is rather caused by an external server that is probably down for good.

Since removing only few medals from a game should not break any stats I'll take a risk ;-)

I'm setting both of these last two to HTTP for good measure.

As for Zomby Birdy there is no reason for that. Those 3 medals stopped working in 2016 - so long before switching the site to https. In this case it is not the reason. Besides, the game fails to connect to the custom levels server on all websites.

At 8/24/18 02:33 PM, HerbieG wrote: As for Zomby Birdy there is no reason for that. Those 3 medals stopped working in 2016 - so long before switching the site to https. In this case it is not the reason. Besides, the game fails to connect to the custom levels server on all websites.

Windy still needs to be removed. Looks like the other custom levels medals were removed but that one was forgotten. Remove it also.

At 8/24/18 07:54 PM, NeonSpider wrote:

Windy still needs to be removed. Looks like the other custom levels medals were removed but that one was forgotten.

Yup! I missed this one!

At 8/24/18 08:50 PM, RightTime wrote: The game Find my Flaws 2 by @PBMCube appears to have all broken medals, since around 2014. Two of the medals have never been unlocked by anyone ever and the other medal was only unlocked by two users on the same day in 2014.
http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/534868

Looks like the medals have been broken for a long time. If they can't be fixed, than they should all be removed.

At 8/24/18 08:50 PM, RightTime wrote: The game Find my Flaws 2 by @PBMCube appears to have all broken medals, since around 2014. Two of the medals have never been unlocked by anyone ever and the other medal was only unlocked by two users on the same day in 2014.
http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/534868

Well, I tried it several times and nothing unlocked, so I took those medals down.
By the way, @TomFulp - read it carefully: when I removed all medals from this game this is how the stats of one of the 2 users that had them unlocked started to look like - see below. Repairing stats fixed the problem, but obviously if there would be a need to remove all medals from a more popular game that solution would be impossible to use. It needs fixing.

By the way, one update and a call for information.
The update:

The author of

• 

  Dukker Tournament

  by JeffAzure

  A series of tournaments. AI Controlled battles.

  Game

  13,096 Views

  (Ages 13+)

removed the medals, because he was unable to fix them.

Now the question. There are some games with questionable medals. They are partially working, partially not. And some clean up would be needed. So here is my question to the recently most active medal hunters @RightTime @NeonSpider @Bobogoobo @Optimos @OneThousandMeeps - were you trying to unlock all the medals in them and if any of them failed, could you post a detailed list? I mean medals that you were absolutely sure you met all the conditions, but they did not unlock:

• 

  Flash Shadowgate

  by larrymcduck

  The NES game Shadowgate recreated in Flash AS2.

  Game

  42,755 Views

  (Ages 13+)

Some of the medals can be hard to determine since they are secret ones.

• 

  Defend your king

  by komizart

  Prepare to be challenged in this unique and exciting castle defense game!

  Game

  43,844 Views

  (Everyone)

The one of hitting the king for the first time is obvious. I also remember I once tried the survival medals and the one for one hour failed to unlock.
In the context of this game I am especially asking for those more "advanced" medals.

• 

  Mutants! Defense

  by Cloudbusting

  Lead brave defenders against blood raged mutants.

  Game

  14,713 Views

  (Ages 13+)

I remember having several problems with this one.

In addition to the question above, another game:

• 

  Drift Raiders

  by Smokoko

  Drive your car and shoot the enemies with different types of weapons.

  Game

  13,695 Views

  (Everyone)

Does anybody know anybody who fulfilled all the requirements for all the medals?
@Glamdrung - do you remember this game?

At 8/25/18 09:29 AM, HerbieG wrote: Now the question. There are some games with questionable medals. They are partially working, partially not. And some clean up would be needed. So here is my question to the recently most active medal hunters @RightTime @NeonSpider @Bobogoobo @Optimos @OneThousandMeeps - were you trying to unlock all the medals in them and if any of them failed, could you post a detailed list? I mean medals that you were absolutely sure you met all the conditions, but they did not unlock:
http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/580801
Some of the medals can be hard to determine since they are secret ones.

Yes. All of the medals that I mentioned in this very thread even. All of the medals that are mentioned by Kitsukage as not working in his review of the game (as of right now, the second review on the front page of the game).

Literally, those.

As for proof the walkthrough in the youtube video in the author comments of the game shows all those medals being unlocked, so you can do the exact same things shown in walkthrough and no medals.

The only unsure one is Rick Roll'd as it's not featured in the walkthrough. You'd have to ask one of the few people who even have that medal to retry getting that medal. Or else just go ahead and remove it as well as it's likely broken since so many others are.

At 8/25/18 09:29 AM, HerbieG wrote: Now the question. There are some games with questionable medals. They are partially working, partially not. And some clean up would be needed. So here is my question to the recently most active medal hunters @RightTime @NeonSpider @Bobogoobo @Optimos @OneThousandMeeps - were you trying to unlock all the medals in them and if any of them failed, could you post a detailed list? I mean medals that you were absolutely sure you met all the conditions, but they did not unlock:
http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/580801
Some of the medals can be hard to determine since they are secret ones.

About Flash Shadowgate: those medals that haven't been unlocked by anyone since 2013 are all broken, without exception. The author replied to one review saying that he'd fix them soon, but he never did, so they should be removed.

And btw, (I know this is off-topic but I want to say it) it'd be great if secret medals displayed their name again instead of '??????'. The name used to be the only hint, and a very useful one, for players to unlock secret medals. Now it's just pure luck.

At 8/25/18 08:01 PM, Optimos wrote:

And btw, (I know this is off-topic but I want to say it) it'd be great if secret medals displayed their name again instead of '??????'. The name used to be the only hint, and a very useful one, for players to unlock secret medals. Now it's just pure luck.

@TomFulp - another "public demand" for you, I already wrote you about it few months ago ;-)

There actually is a way to see the titles of the secret medals, but not directly. They are still properly displayed on medal walls, so all you have to do is open a medal wall of anybody that earned at least one medal of a game. If you did it - you can check your own wall as well.